Explanation
The combination ?! labels a move as dubious or questionable. The annotator sees a defect and believes that a better option probably existed, although the move may still contain a useful idea or be hard to prove wrong.
It is usually milder criticism than . It may flag a somewhat inferior choice, unnecessary risk, a weakness that remains in the position, or a trap that works only if the opponent responds poorly.
It should not be read like . The order changes the emphasis: ?! begins with doubt; !? begins with interest. A program may read ?! in Portable Game Notation (PGN), the plain-text game format. When saving the file in standard form, it replaces ?! with $6, a dollar sign followed by the number 6.
Common confusions
?! and !?
?! leans toward criticism; !? leans toward the interest of an uncertain idea.
View termQuestionable and losing
A ?! move can be inferior without losing immediately or completely ruining the position.
Sources
- 1.Standard: Portable Game Notation Specification and Implementation Guide, rec.games.chess contributors; coordinated by Steven J. Edwards
- 2.System of Signs, Chess Informant
- 3.Chess annotation symbols, Wikimedia Foundation
