Explanation
An annotation symbol adds a brief judgment to a recorded game. It can assess a move, as ! or ? does, or describe the resulting position, as =, ∞, or ± does. The symbol communicates an analytical idea without requiring a full sentence.
Move annotations
- !: good move
- ?: poor move or mistake
- !!: excellent or especially strong move
- ??: serious blunder
- !?: interesting or speculative move
- ?!: dubious move
These marks contain the judgment of the human or software annotator. Two authors may disagree over whether a move deserves ! or !?, and labels such as mistake or brilliant depend on the surrounding position.
Position assessments
Position symbols summarize who stands better or how clear the assessment is. The means balanced; means unclear; ± and ∓ favor White or Black. These are qualitative categories, not official results or exact numerical scores.
In PGN, many judgments are stored as , codes such as $1 or $16. Software can render the stored code as the familiar visible mark.
Not every mark in chess notation is an annotation. The capture x, check +, checkmate #, and the = used in promotion have objective jobs inside the move notation. An annotation symbol adds an evaluation instead.
Common confusions
Judgment versus move fact
! and ? judge quality; x, +, and # describe what the move objectively does under the rules.
Symbol versus NAG
The symbol is the visible mark; a NAG is the numeric code that can store it in PGN.
Sources
- 1.Portable Game Notation Specification and Implementation Guide, Steven J. Edwards
- 2.System of Signs, Chess Informant
