Explanation
Two exclamation marks, !!, label a move as very good, outstanding, or brilliant. The mark is often used for a decision that is difficult to find, surprising, or especially deep.
There is no universal test that forces an annotator to use !!. One writer may reward a precise sequence of moves, another the only defense that works, and another a creative idea. The symbol therefore expresses human judgment even when computer analysis supports it.
gives more moderate praise. does not mean brilliant; it means interesting or speculative. A program may read !! in Portable Game Notation (PGN), the plain-text game format. When saving the file in standard form, it replaces !! with $3, a dollar sign followed by the number 3.
Common confusions
Brilliant and forced
!! praises the quality or difficulty of a move; by itself it does not say that the move was the only legal or winning choice.
!! and !?
!! is strong praise; !? marks an interesting idea whose correctness may remain uncertain.
View termSources
- 1.Standard: Portable Game Notation Specification and Implementation Guide, rec.games.chess contributors; coordinated by Steven J. Edwards
- 2.System of Signs, Chess Informant
- 3.Chess annotation symbols, Wikimedia Foundation
