Saavedra position

The Saavedra position is a composed study with only four pieces: White king and pawn against Black king and rook. A study is a constructed position designed to contain a unique or especially instructive solution. Although the rook appears able to stop the pawn, White wins by calculating both the checks and the choice of promotion piece.

When a pawn reaches the last rank, it may become a queen, rook, bishop, or knight. Choosing a queen is normal, but it fails here. In algebraic notation, which names every square by file and rank, c8=Q means that the pawn reaches c8 and becomes a queen. The ? sign marks the move as a mistake. After 6.c8=Q? Black has 6...Rc4+, and 7.Qxc4 is stalemate because the black king is not in check and has no legal move.

Standard promotion and stalemate resource

The queen allows the resource

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

a1

b

c

d

e

f

g

h

Start

c8=Q

Rc4+

Qxc4

Critical moment

The white pawn is on c7 and can promote. The choice of piece determines which legal resources remain available to the black rook.

The solution is 6.c8=R , promotion to a rook. This preserves the win without allowing the same stalemate trap. After 6...Ra4 7.Kb3, the black rook cannot survive White's threats. The lesson is not to choose a weaker piece for spectacle, but to compare which legal replies each promotion leaves the opponent.

Underpromotion that preserves the win

The rook changes the replies

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

a1

b

c

d

e

f

g

h

Start

c8=R

Ra4

Kb3

The same critical moment

The initial position is identical to the other branch. Only the piece chosen for promotion changes.

Fernando Saavedra found this possibility in 1895 after the position had been presented as a draw. The study became a classic example of underpromotion, the name for promotion to any piece other than a queen.